TextMagic vs. Medallia Concierge: SMS Marketing Solution Comparison 2025

Overview: TextMagic and Medallia Concierge as SMS Marketing Category solutions.

TextMagic and Medallia Concierge are dynamic players in the SMS marketing space, each offering distinct solutions tailored to various business needs. TextMagic excels in comprehensive communication and integration features, making it a choice for IT and software fields. Medallia Concierge shines in engagement and social media management, focusing strongly on the hospitality industry. Both products emphasize robust support, catering to enterprises and large businesses seeking customer acquisition and enhanced communication.

TextMagic: Textmagic is an all-in-one business texting solution for marketing, two-way SMS, notifications, and staff communication. Business texting needs are efficiently managed with Textmagic.

Medallia Concierge: Medallia Concierge personalizes and elevates customer experiences through intelligent text and in-app messaging. Customer loyalty is built, and results are delivered effectively.

TextMagic and Medallia Concierge: Best Use cases based on the customer satisfaction data

Key Capabilities Supported

TextMagic leads in communication management, focusing on sending communications and managing contact lists. read more →

Medallia Concierge specializes in engagement management and robust communication processes. read more →

Business Goals

TextMagic helps acquire customers and improve internal communications and customer relationships. read more →

Medallia Concierge focuses on acquiring customers and increasing sales and revenue. read more →

Core Features

TextMagic is lauded for its integration and security, providing custom reports and data import capabilities. read more →

Medallia Concierge has strong analytics and AI features, with ease of integration. read more →

Vendor Support

TextMagic offers 24/7 support, with email and phone options available to address client needs. read more →

Medallia Concierge supports through 24/7 service, including phone and chat support assistance. read more →

Segments and Industries

TextMagic serves mostly large enterprises and IT services, with a presence in automotive and software. read more →

Medallia Concierge is favored by enterprises in hospitality and nonprofit sectors. read more →

Operational Alignment

TextMagic is ideal for large-scale operations needing comprehensive communication features. read more →

Medallia Concierge fits well with enterprises focusing on engagement and social media. read more →

Applying your context and needs changes the comparison

Failure Risk Guidance?

Low Medium High

Compliance Risk

low

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

medium

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

Security & Privacy Risk

low

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

medium

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

Integration Risk

low

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

medium

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

Migration Risk

medium

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

low

{{{rsh_C_1}}}

IT and Other Capabilities

Low
Medium
High

Ease of migration

Read peer / expert warnings.

Data

Data Import

Read peer / expert warnings.

Data Export

Read peer / expert warnings.

Support

Email Support

Read peer / expert warnings.

Chat Support

Read peer / expert warnings.

Phone Support

Read peer / expert warnings.

24/7 Support

Read peer / expert warnings.

Others

Custom Reports

Read peer / expert warnings.

Analytics

Read peer / expert warnings.

AI Powered

Read peer / expert warnings.

Most deployed common Use Cases for TextMagic and Medallia Concierge

What benefits does TextMagic and Medallia Concierge offer for Communication Management?

Textmagic and Medallia Concierge both facilitate sending text messages to multiple recipients. Textmagic offers a wider range of features including two-way chat and the ability to send messages through email, while Medallia Concierge focuses on automated messages and multi-channel communication. Textmagic has limitations in its cost for sending SMS messages, while Medallia Concierge lacks the ability to send group message threads.

"...It allows us to send text messages from the office using a full sized keyboard and to store incoming messages along with emails. ...." Peer review by Alan D., Busness Owner, Marketing and Advertising

"...When our guest sends a text message request via Zingle, the message gets automatically sent to the right department and the HotSOS service ticket is created seamlessly. . ...." Peer review by Roland I., Instant Service Manager, Hospitality

What benefits does TextMagic and Medallia Concierge offer for Engagement Management?

Textmagic and Medallia Concierge both facilitate customer engagement through messaging platforms. Textmagic focuses on using SMS to organize campaigns, track customer interactions, and improve communication. Medallia Concierge emphasizes engagement through various messaging channels, including SMS, Facebook Messenger, and LINE, aiming to personalize communication and improve customer satisfaction.

"...We reached our campaign goals in terms of subscriptions and engagement...." Peer review by Kendrick J, IT Specialist

"...With Zingle, we decrease the amount of phone calls and keep our staff engaged with customers at the front counter...." Peer review by Nathaly Ortega

How does TextMagic and Medallia Concierge address your Contact List Management Challenges?

Both Textmagic and Medallia Concierge allow for the management and organization of contact lists, facilitating communication with customers and stakeholders. Textmagic offers features such as contact import and list organization, while Medallia Concierge provides tagging and segmentation tools for categorizing contacts. Both platforms enable businesses to send messages and manage communications efficiently. However, Textmagic has a limitation in its upload function for contacts, which is reported to be unreliable.

"...Although the pricing is a little higher as compared to the local providers, I do recommend for they are a comprehensive service and will provide a centralized, updated system for contacts management and for launching SMS campaigns...." Peer review by Trisha D, Director

"...Easy to use to contact customers to confirm appointments and to schedule dates...." Peer review by Jonathon Vitek

Why is TextMagic and Medallia Concierge the best choice for Workflow Management?

Textmagic and Medallia Concierge both offer workflow management capabilities. Textmagic focuses on integrating SMS messaging into workflows, enabling businesses to add text messaging features to their websites and software. Medallia Concierge emphasizes automation, using an automated workflow engine to streamline communication and create custom communication workflows.